Topps 1969 American League All Star Infield was another head scratcher. At second Topps had Rod Carew who was the 1968 All Star starter and a 1969 Sporting News All Star selection. Similarly, third base was Brooks Robinson. He was the 1968 ASG starter and a 1969 Sporting News All Star. There if falls apart.
Topps had Bert Campaneris at shortstop. The actual 1969 Sporting News All Star was Luis Aparicio. The 1968 MLB All Star Game Starter was Jim Fregosi.
At first it gets really strange. Topps had Ken Harrelson who had been used primarily as an outfielder since being dealt to the Red Sox in 1967. In fact, he was named to The Sporting News All Star team in 1969 as an outfielder, not a first baseman. He also appears to be in his A's uniform despite being traded in 1967. The actual 1969 Sporting News All Star in 1969 was Boog Powell and the starting first baseman in the 1968 All Star Game was Harmon Killebrew.
Who probably didn't merit inclusion in the 1969 Topps All-Star set, but was in it anyway?
Bert Campaneris:
We'll give Topps a pass for Hawk Harrelson because he was a Sporting News Selection in 1969, although in the OF not 1B. But Campy made his first ASG appearance in 1968 as a reserve and wouldn't be named to The Sporting News team until 1973. Additionally, the pinstriped uniform in the picture hasn't been worn by the A's in the regular season since 1961. How old is this picture?
Fantastic looking cards. Hard to decide, but I think the Killer card is the best. Agree 100% on those that probably didn't merit inclusion. Good players, but not the best at their positions at that time.
ReplyDelete